Correct Answer:
A. My aunt, who lives in Karachi, is a doctor.
Correct answer: My aunt, who lives in Karachi, is a doctor.. Because the speaker has only one aunt, the clause who lives in Karachi is extra information, so it is set off with a pair of commas.
Background: A non-restrictive relative clause adds detail that can be removed without changing the main meaning, and it is always enclosed in commas.
- My aunt who lives in Karachi, is a doctor.: Only one comma is used; the clause needs a comma on both sides.
- My aunt, who lives in Karachi is a doctor.: The opening comma is present, but the closing comma after Karachi is missing.
- My aunt who lives, in Karachi is a doctor.: The comma is wrongly placed inside the clause, after lives.
Did you know? If the speaker had several aunts, the clause would identify which aunt and no commas would be used.
Memory trick: Extra information gets a comma pair.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.